“Earth Day” dumped, "Triage Day" declared

Here is a great dark humor about Earth Day, by ClimateProgress blogger Joe Romm:
http://climateprogress.org/2009/04/19/renameearth-day-humor-triage-i-tol...

My comments to him is below:

Joe,

Great dark humor! I like "Triage Day".

But I disagree fundamentally with your assertion that we could somehow focus on saving the soon-to-be 9 billion human population. The fact is that the larger the human population, the more important the integrity of the rest of the ecosystems is in sustaining our very survival. To put it in other words, for a small human population, we may be able to scrape a living on a devastated planet with small niches of ecosystems left, but with 9 bln to sustain, we need mostly intact, functioning ecosystems. The scary thing is that, it is well known that ecosystem diversity (i.e., the complexity of the eco-web) is directly associated with its robustness, and determines the residence time of both energy and biomass (including carbon) passing through the biosphere. AND, loss of ecosystem diversity is, just like climate responses, a non-linear process, and entire ecosystem collapses can happen abruptly when stressed to a breaking point. A great book with discussion on this is "The Rainbow and the Worm - the physics of organisms", by biophysicist Mae-wan Ho. See chapter 4 p.58, chapter 6 p. 80.

Tim R. commented above that, in the long run "Earth will some day again be in balance and humans will be here". Not necessarily. James Hansen and co-authors pointed out that, unlike runaway snowball Earth condition, for which there is a natural mechanism with with Earth will eventually escape out of (which it did in the past), a runaway global warming, once beyond a certain point, will be forever, and there is no planetary mechanism that we know of that will naturally bring an end to it. Venus is apparently in that state.

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.